On three words in Sarah Mullally’s address in Belfast
‘We cannot simply vote trust into existence, nor can we create hope through anxiety, fear or urgency.’
Sarah Mullally, Belfast, 28 June 2026[1]
On 28 June 2026, in her presidential address to the Anglican Consultative Council, the Archbishop of Canterbury spoke a sentence that the Council would make its own in the days that followed. The first half concerns voting. The second turns on three words: anxiety, fear, urgency. This essay dwells on those words – on what they do to those who think differently, and on the way the Archbishop herself has used the vote, and fear, on other occasions.
The sentence names no one. It has no need to. In Belfast the Council was to discuss proposals which, among other things, sought to ‘decenter the Archbishop of Canterbury’s role’ in the Communion’s structures.[2] Those who were asking for change, and asking for a decision, were for the most part provinces of the Global South and delegates who spoke of a Communion already broken. One of them was the Chilean delegate, Carlos Romero, who asked for the resolution’s definition of the Communion in terms of full communion with Canterbury to be removed, since it did ‘not reflect the lived reality of many provinces today’.[3]
The address had described them in advance. Hope, the Archbishop said, cannot be created through anxiety, fear or urgency. And in the following paragraph she added that ‘the temptation for any family under pressure is to seek immediate solutions’.[4]
Those words do not engage with what the other person says. They describe his state of mind. Whoever asks for a decision is cast as someone with a problem, and his reasons cease to be heard. The argument is turned into a symptom.
The move is hard to answer. Whoever replies ‘I am not anxious’ confirms, in the speaker’s eyes, that he is. Whoever presses for a decision seems to prove his urgency. And all of it is done in the vocabulary of pastoral care, so that to object looks like a want of charity.
The word ‘immediate’ makes matters worse. The provinces of the South have been waiting for an answer since 2003, when the Episcopal Church in the United States consecrated as bishop a man living in a partnership with another man. Since then there has been the Windsor Report, a number of Primates’ Meetings, a Covenant that came to nothing, and two Lambeth Conferences. It is not fair to describe as ‘immediate solutions’ what has been sought for twenty-three years.
A way of speaking with a history
This is not the first time the Archbishop has described those who disagree in such terms. In November 2023, as Bishop of London, she opened the General Synod debate on prayers of blessing for same-sex couples. She acknowledged ‘the profound disagreement that exists across the Church of England’. But she also said that ‘we need, I believe, to resist those who wish to separate themselves or others from the body’.[5] Those who opposed the prayers in conscience were thereby described as people who wanted to divide.
The first half of the Belfast sentence says that trust cannot be voted into existence. The Archbishop’s recent record shows that she has found the vote a perfectly good instrument when the result moved in the direction she was proposing.
On 9 February 2023 the General Synod passed the motion welcoming prayers for same-sex couples. She had introduced it herself.[6] The bishops voted 36 in favour and 4 against; the clergy, 111 to 85; the laity, 103 to 92.[7] She did not say then that trust cannot be created by voting.
In November 2023 the Archbishop, still Bishop of London, moved the next motion. It passed in the House of Laity by 104 votes to 100.[8] An amendment to trial standalone services for such couples passed among the laity by 99 votes to 98.[9] A margin of a single vote was enough to move forward.
Eleven days after the February vote, the primates of the Global South Fellowship declared that the Church of England had ‘disqualified herself from leading the Communion as the historic “Mother” Church’, and that they were no longer able to recognise the Archbishop of Canterbury as ‘first among equals’.[10] The vote had created anything but trust. Yet that did not halt the process in England.
In Belfast, too, there was a vote. It was on a resolution drafted by the Standing Committee, of which the Archbishop is a member – a resolution that quotes her sentence about trust and defines the Communion in terms of full communion with Canterbury. It passed by 72 votes to 8.[11] Romero’s amendments were defeated, the first by 52 to 24.[12] What was not put to the vote were the proposals that would have reduced Canterbury’s role.
The rule, then, works in one direction only. There is a vote when voting advances things in the desired direction, or confirms what already exists. When a vote might change what one does not wish to change, everyone is reminded that trust cannot be voted into existence.
Four days after the opening address, the Archbishop spoke to the Council again. She warned that losing the description of being ‘in communion with the See of Canterbury’ could have ‘unexpected consequences’ for relations with ecumenical partners and with world leaders, the United Nations among them.[13]
It is a legitimate argument. But it is, in substance, an appeal to the fear of consequences. The same person who on the first day had ruled out fear as a basis for decisions reached for it when the standing of her own see was at stake. The fear of others was anxiety. Her own was prudence.
The story did not begin in Belfast. In February 2023, in Accra, at the previous meeting of the Council, the then Archbishop, Justin Welby, said: ‘I will not cling to place or position as an Instrument of Communion’, and that ‘the Instruments must change with the times’. He added a condition: ‘I hold it very lightly, provided that the other Instruments of Communion choose the new shape’.[14] In the same address he insisted that the Church of England would not be ‘blackmailed, bribed to do what others want us to do’.[15] The Council then asked the commission IASCUFO to explore the Communion’s structure and decision-making, and to bring to its next meeting any proposals that might affect its Constitution.[16]
Three years later, in Belfast, Welby’s successor said that ‘maybe we are not quite there yet’. The proposals were received as resources, and the decision was deferred to 2029. Three years after one archbishop said he would not cling to his place, that place remains intact. The Belfast resolution, moreover, describes it with a formula – ‘full communion’ – that is stronger than the wording of the Council’s own Constitution.[17]
The journalist George Conger read Welby’s offer as early as 2023 as a way of avoiding a confrontation that might have cost him his position, in the very days when the primates of the South were ceasing to recognise him as first among equals.[18] That is an interpretation. What followed does not refute it.
It is as well, nonetheless, not to oversimplify. The proposals to decentre Canterbury were largely prepared by English churchmen. The commission was chaired by an English bishop, Graham Tomlin, and Andrew Atherstone, of Oxford, contributed to them. In Belfast, moreover, Canterbury’s place was defended by delegates from Australia, Canada, Ireland and South Africa.[19] The Church of England did not act as a bloc, nor was it alone in wanting nothing to change.
What can be affirmed is a pattern. Each opening comes with a condition, and each decision is postponed. There is no need to suppose a plan. It is enough to notice that an institution which loses power if a decision is taken has every incentive to see that no decision is taken – and that this institution controls the agenda, the procedure and the timetable.
Whoever controls everything can afford to be magnanimous
In Belfast the Archbishop controlled more than the agenda. Her address set the frame of the discussion, the committee on which she sits drafted the resolution, and the outcome placed the next step in a Primates’ Meeting that she convenes and left the decisions for 2029.[20]
When one controls the agenda, the procedure, the timetable and the next steps, magnanimous language costs nothing. One can invite others to listen without haste, because only those who are waiting are in a hurry. One can speak of patience, because time runs in favour of whoever already occupies the centre. And one can forgo the vote, because the vote was only ever needed by those who wanted to change something.
It may be that the Archbishop sincerely believes in patience and in listening. But words have effects, and these had a very clear one. They turned the objection of those who were asking for an answer into an emotional problem.
Jesus asked his disciples to let their yes be yes and their no be no (Matthew 5:37). The teaching applies to the language of those who govern the Church as well. If trust cannot be created by voting, that should hold equally in London and in Belfast. If fear is a poor basis for decisions, that should hold equally for the South’s fear of losing the faith once received and for Canterbury’s fear of losing its place.
The provinces that asked for a decision in Belfast were not anxious. They were weary of waiting. The address did not register that difference, and in that difference lies the heart of the matter.
[1] Sarah Mullally, ‘Archbishop of Canterbury’s Presidential Address to the Anglican Consultative Council’, Belfast, 28 June 2026, archbishopofcanterbury.org (accessed 19 October 2026), para. 21. The sentence was taken up in Resolutions of the Anglican Consultative Council, Belfast, 2026, Resolution 2, clause 4.
[2] Mark Michael, ‘Mullally Calls ACC to Deepened Hope and Trust’, The Living Church, 28 June 2026. Full wording: ‘decenter the Archbishop of Canterbury’s role in its structures’.
[3] Mark Michael, ‘ACC Debates Nairobi-Cairo Proposals, Elects Leaders’, The Living Church, 4 July 2026.
[4] Mullally, Belfast address, paras 21 and 22.
[5] Sarah Mullally, ‘Prayers of Love and Faith debate: Bishop of London’s address to Synod’, Church of England, 14 November 2023. The address ends with ‘I move the motion’.
[6] ‘Church of England General Synod Endorses Bishops’ Proposal for Same-Sex Blessings’, Episcopal News Service, 9 February 2023: ‘introduced by Bishop of London Sarah Mullally’.
[7] Church of England, General Synod, Business Done, 9 February 2023, vote by houses: bishops 36–4 (2 abstentions); clergy 111–85 (3); laity 103–92 (5).
[8] Church of England, General Synod, Business Done, 15 November 2023, vote by houses: bishops 23–10 (4 abstentions); clergy 100–93 (1); laity 104–100.
[9] Francis Martin, ‘General Synod Agrees to Trial Services for Same-Sex Couples after Marathon Debate’, Church Times, 15 November 2023. The amendment passed in the House of Laity by 99 votes to 98, with two abstentions.
[10] Global South Fellowship of Anglican Churches, Ash Wednesday Statement of GSFA Primates on the Church of England’s Decision regarding the Blessing of Same Sex Unions, 20 February 2023. Full wording: ‘no longer able to recognise the present Archbishop of Canterbury […] as the “first among equals” Leader of the global Communion’.
[11] David Paulsen, ‘ACC Leaves Archbishop of Canterbury’s Role Unchanged in Ongoing Talks on Anglican Identity’, Episcopal News Service, 4 July 2026: ‘72 ACC members supporting the resolution and eight against’.
[12] Michael, ‘ACC Debates Nairobi-Cairo Proposals, Elects Leaders’; Andrew Atherstone, ‘Hope for the Communion? Reflections on the Anglican Consultative Council’s 2026 Meeting’, The Living Church, 8 July 2026: ‘52 votes to 24 with 4 abstentions’.
[13] Mark Michael, ‘Mullally on Nairobi-Cairo Proposals: “We’re Not There Yet”’, The Living Church, 2 July 2026. Atherstone, ‘Hope for the Communion?’, confirms the reference to ecumenical partners and to the United Nations.
[14] Justin Welby, presidential address at ACC-18, Accra, February 2023, quoted in George Conger, ‘Welby Proposes Pulling Canterbury out of Anglican Instruments of Communion’, Anglican Ink, 12 February 2023. The full address is available at archbishopofcanterbury.org.
[15] Ibid.
[16] Anglican Consultative Council, Resolutions of ACC-18, Accra, 2023, Resolution 3(a): ‘to explore theological questions regarding structure and decision-making to help address our differences’; ‘Asks IASCUFO for any proposals that may impact the ACC constitution to be brought for full discussion to ACC-19’.
[17] Michael, ‘Mullally on Nairobi-Cairo Proposals: “We’re Not There Yet”’. Resolutions of the Anglican Consultative Council, Belfast, 2026, Resolution 2, clauses 1, 6 and 7. On the Council’s Constitution, which speaks of being ‘in communion with the Archbishop of Canterbury’: Atherstone, ‘Hope for the Communion?’.
[18] Conger, ‘Welby Proposes Pulling Canterbury out of Anglican Instruments of Communion’.
[19] On Tomlin as chair of the commission: Pat Ashworth, ‘Anglican Consultative Council Debates Nairobi-Cairo Proposals on Future of Communion’, Church Times, 30 June 2026. On Atherstone, introduced as ‘one of the contributors to the proposals’: Andrew Atherstone, ‘What Is the Future of the Anglican Communion?’, Psephizo, n.d. On the delegates from Australia, Canada and Ireland: Mark Michael, ‘ACC Members Doubtful About Nairobi-Cairo Proposals’, The Living Church, 30 June 2026, in which Archbishop Kay Goldsworthy of Australia asks: ‘what is our rallying point; what binds us?’. On South Africa: Michael, ‘Mullally on Nairobi-Cairo Proposals’.
[20] Resolutions, Resolution 2, clause 7(a) and (b): ‘welcomes the Archbishop of Canterbury’s intention […] to call a Primates’ Meeting’; ‘report back and decision-making at ACC20’.